| Current Holder | Previous Holders |
|---|---|
| Kiros Silverveil | Felicia Zucker1 |
| Anna Somerset1 | |
| Felicia Zucker3, 1 | |
| Samantha Taser Kennedy1 | |
| Shadowscale1 | |
| Dwight Slade | |
| Neon Shadow2 | |
| Dwight Slade | |
| Revenant Rose1 |
1 - Wrestler retired
2 - Reign lasted one night, thereafter dubbed the 'Macho Minute'
3 - Reign lasted one night